Disciplinary procedures for employers

Wake Smith Solicitors 23 July 2018

Disciplinary procedures deal with difficulties arising in the employment relationship.

They are sometimes the best way for an employer to tell an employee when something is wrong.

It allows them to explain clearly what improvement is needed and should give an employee the opportunity to put forward their side of the situation.

Mark Serby, director and head of employment law, explores the procedures, policies and practices involved.

“The prospect of conducting a disciplinary is rarely an enticing one for employers and employees.

“This makes it essential to have a robust disciplinary procedure in place so that there are a clear set of guidelines to follow in the event of a potentially difficult situation.

“Employers use disciplinary procedures to tell employees that their performance or conduct isn't up to the expected standard and to encourage improvement.

“Employees can be dismissed lawfully. Generally, employers must ensure that they have a fair reason for dismissal, follow a fair procedure and act fairly and reasonably - so as to avoid unfair dismissal.

“They must comply with the terms of the employment contract, particularly with regards to the employee's notice period to avoid wrongful dismissal, and must not discriminate unlawfully.

“Employees are entitled, in some cases, to written reasons for dismissal. There must be a fair reason for the dismissal.”

There are five potentially fair reasons for dismissal:

  • Conduct – this could be a single act of misconduct or a series of less serious acts.
  • Capability or qualifications - including poor performance, ill-health and formal qualifications
  • Redundancy – this includes workplace closure, business closure, or a reduced need for employees.
  • Illegality - where continuing to employ the employee in the position they hold would contravene a   statutory restriction (for example, because of their immigration status)
  • "Some other substantial reason" (SOSR) - a catch-all category of potentially fair reasons that do not fall under the other categories. This may include dismissals for failure to agree to changes to terms and conditions, pressure from third parties such as clients, and business reorganisations falling short of a genuine redundancy situation.

Mark said: “I am often asked whether a HR manager can conduct a disciplinary hearing.

“My advice would be that it would be important that the HR manager had no involvement in advising the investigating officer and that they would not be involved in advising in relation to any appeal.

“Their role in relation to the incident in question would need to be limited to hearing and deciding the disciplinary.  This can be difficult in a small HR team.  In addition, the wider HR team would need to refrain from interfering with their colleague's decision.

“Small employers also often struggle to find separate people to carry out the investigation and disciplinary process.

“In relation to dismissals in misconduct cases, where practicable, different people should carry out the investigation and disciplinary hearing.

“Therefore an employer would have to be able to demonstrate that it was not practicable for different people to be involved in the two stages.

“Failure to comply could lead to an uplift in any Employment Tribunal award for unfair dismissal by up to 25 per cent.

“An employer will be judged by the objective standards of the hypothetical reasonable employer and, ultimately, whether a particular course of action is reasonable will be a matter for an Emplyment Tribunal to determine in all the circumstances of a particular case.”

Sometimes, employers have to deal with grievances during disciplinary proceedings.

Mark added: “Where an employee raises a grievance during a disciplinary process, the disciplinary process may be temporarily suspended in order to deal with the grievance.

“Where the grievance and disciplinary cases are related it may be appropriate to deal with both issues concurrently.”

Can an employer dismiss an employee during their probationary period without following its disciplinary procedure?

Mark said: “In these circumstances, it is likely to be advisable to explain the problems to the employee and give them an opportunity to improve.

“If it doesn't work out their contract can be terminated. This is, after all, what the probationary period is for.

“If you have a procedure for dealing with poor performance, this should be followed in dealing with the employee, in particular, how you would usually set out problems and provide opportunities for improvement.”

Should an employer obtain a medical report to confirm whether an employee suffering from stress is fit to attend a disciplinary hearing?

Mark said: “An employer should ask themselves whether the stress or anxiety caused or contributed to the poor performance in the first place.

“Where this is a possibility, an employer may wish to consider whether it is appropriate to suspend the disciplinary hearing or even drop it entirely, and then assess the situation using the HSE’s Stress Management Standards, providing support for the employee as appropriate.

“If an employer is concerned that the disciplinary hearing may add to the employee’s stress or anxiety, medical advice may be obtained as to whether the employee is fit to attend a disciplinary hearing, and if not, when they might be.”

Can a lenient disciplinary penalty be increased on appeal?

Mark said: “An appeal must never be used as an opportunity to punish the employee for appealing the original decision, and it should not result in any increase in penalty, as this may deter individuals from appealing.

“However, ultimately the question for the tribunal would be whether the employer's decision to dismiss was within the band of reasonable responses.”

Set the standards and communicate

Mark added: “In order to operate effectively, organisations need to set standards for performance and conduct – and staff need to know what these are.

“Cases of minor misconduct or unsatisfactory performance are usually best dealt with informally. A quiet word is often all that is required to improve an employee's conduct or performance.

“However, where formal action is needed, promptness, fairness and consistency are key to investigations to gather and establish all the facts of the case.”

For further information on disciplinary procedures and other employment matters contact Mark Serby at at [email protected] or on 0114 224 2048

Tags

Archive

March 20247February 20242January 20248December 20236November 20232October 20235September 20232August 20234July 20232June 20235May 20238March 20234February 20235January 20233December 20225November 20224October 20224September 20223August 20221June 20221May 20227April 20223March 20223February 20223January 20224December 20214November 20213October 20215September 20216August 20212July 202111June 20218May 20216April 20212March 20218February 20218January 20219December 20208November 202013October 20209September 20208August 20203July 20208June 202016May 202013April 20209March 202016February 20209January 202011December 20199November 20199October 201911September 20195August 20194July 20196May 20198April 20196March 20193February 20195January 20194December 20186November 20185October 20182September 20185August 20184July 20189June 20184May 201810April 20185March 20184February 20184January 20183December 20175November 20178October 20177September 20179August 20175July 20176June 201710May 20176April 20178March 201711February 20176January 201712December 20169November 20167October 201610September 201610August 20166July 20167June 20163May 20162April 20166March 20162February 20164January 20165December 20153November 20155October 20156September 20156August 20157July 20157June 20157May 20156April 20159March 20156February 201510January 20156December 20145November 20144October 20142September 20143May 20144March 20146February 20144January 20142December 20132November 20133September 20134July 20132June 20132May 20133April 20131March 20133February 20133January 20136December 20121November 20123October 20122August 20122July 20128June 20123April 20123March 20121January 20124December 20112November 20111October 20112September 20113August 20113July 20117June 20119May 20117April 20115March 20119February 20118January 20111December 20101October 20102September 20102August 20103July 20106June 20101May 20102April 20106March 20102February 20103January 20102December 20095November 20092October 20092September 20092August 20091July 20095June 20095May 20093April 20093March 20093February 20091January 20092November 20082October 20082September 20081August 20083July 20081January 20082

Featured Articles

Contact us