DPA - Access request refused where GP exposed to negligence claim

Wake Smith Solicitors 05 October 2016

The High Court has given some further guidance on the difficult balancing exercise where data make subject access requests (SAR) and there is potential litigation in view.

A GP has successfully overturned the General Medical Council’s (GMC) decision to disclose an expert report on his professional competence to a former patient following a SAR. The case arose out of a delay in diagnosis of bladder cancer and in the course of investigation the GMC obtained an independent expert’s report concerning the GP’s professional competence. A 1 page summary was sent by the GMC to the patient, the patient then submitted a SAR. The GP refused consent on the basis that it was his personal data and that the purpose of the request was litigation. The GMC however decided to disclose the report taking into account of the importance of the transparency of its decision making process. The High Court acknowledged the competing rights of both patient and GP. However, following Court of Appeal guidelines in a 2003 case, the GMC’s starting point should have been against disclosure where litigation was to follow. The GMC failed to give adequate reflection in the balancing exercise to the fact that the data was arguably primarily that of the GP’s rather than the patients as it centred on his professional competence. The refusal of the GP to consent to disclosure should have been given more weight. Other routes to disclosure using court procedures were available if litigation followed and that was also a consideration. Some useful guidance was provided by the Judge.

Note: Section 7 of the Data Protection Act 1998 provides that individuals have the right of access to their personal data. Third party interests are protected by Section 7(4) and (5). The data controller often has to balance the rights of the SAR against the rights of an identifiable individual who may refuse consent. Section 7(6) identifies four non-exhaustive factors in the balancing factors in the balancing exercise and the case centred on this provision. Civil Procedure Rule 31 provides for the disclosure of documents in civil proceedings.

For further information on data protection please contact Holly Dobson on 0114 224 2121 or at [email protected]

Tags

Archive

March 20247February 20242January 20248December 20236November 20232October 20235September 20232August 20234July 20232June 20235May 20238March 20234February 20235January 20233December 20225November 20224October 20224September 20223August 20221June 20221May 20227April 20223March 20223February 20223January 20224December 20214November 20213October 20215September 20216August 20212July 202111June 20218May 20216April 20212March 20218February 20218January 20219December 20208November 202013October 20209September 20208August 20203July 20208June 202016May 202013April 20209March 202016February 20209January 202011December 20199November 20199October 201911September 20195August 20194July 20196May 20198April 20196March 20193February 20195January 20194December 20186November 20185October 20182September 20185August 20184July 20189June 20184May 201810April 20185March 20184February 20184January 20183December 20175November 20178October 20177September 20179August 20175July 20176June 201710May 20176April 20178March 201711February 20176January 201712December 20169November 20167October 201610September 201610August 20166July 20167June 20163May 20162April 20166March 20162February 20164January 20165December 20153November 20155October 20156September 20156August 20157July 20157June 20157May 20156April 20159March 20156February 201510January 20156December 20145November 20144October 20142September 20143May 20144March 20146February 20144January 20142December 20132November 20133September 20134July 20132June 20132May 20133April 20131March 20133February 20133January 20136December 20121November 20123October 20122August 20122July 20128June 20123April 20123March 20121January 20124December 20112November 20111October 20112September 20113August 20113July 20117June 20119May 20117April 20115March 20119February 20118January 20111December 20101October 20102September 20102August 20103July 20106June 20101May 20102April 20106March 20102February 20103January 20102December 20095November 20092October 20092September 20092August 20091July 20095June 20095May 20093April 20093March 20093February 20091January 20092November 20082October 20082September 20081August 20083July 20081January 20082

Featured Articles

Contact us